Skip to contentSkip to the Reading Area

BenBiz Reading Area (Külliyat)

Begin with a question.
Go deeper at your pace.

Search for an answer, choose a topic or follow a reading path into BenBiz. Start with a short explanation, then explore the current guide and its unchanged original source. Reading is open to everyone; no account is needed.

31 bilingual web guides3 different reading paths17 original sources preserved
People across generations exploring a visual map together in a warm learning space by a lake; representative illustration
What we learn together makes the next step easier. Representative image.

Questions and short answers

Get to know BenBiz.

Open the question on your mind. Each short answer leads to a guide you can explore.

01I am new here. Where should I begin?

Follow the quick introduction path through four guides on why BenBiz exists, the circle and shared responsibility. You do not need an account to read.

Open the introduction path
02How do I join Build Together and find my reply?

Open an area that interests you through Build Together. If a call is open for applications, read its terms. After you apply, follow the reply in My Applications and the notification bell in the app.

See the participation steps
03Can I contribute without joining a circle?

Yes. With an Explorer Member account, you can add a question, correction, experience or source to a guide. You do not need to be a circle member.

See the Explorer Member path
04How can I take part in decisions?

The Shared Decisions guide uses examples to show how a proposal is opened, how views and votes are gathered, and how the decision is followed through.

Read the decision examples
05Could something I no longer use help someone else begin?

Shelves in storage, an unused afternoon or a familiar skill could be someone else’s missing piece. Follow three illustrative scenes in which people discuss an exchange on their own terms.

Read the Exchange examples
06How do we agree on what I receive for my contribution?

Expecting no return and waiting for compensation are different choices. Agree on the contribution, the part paid now and the conditions for anything left outstanding. Sharing a surplus needs separate terms.

Read about contributions and rights
07How does a current guide differ from its original source?

For today’s workflow, read the dated web guide. To see how the thinking developed, follow the link in the guide to the unchanged original source.

See how guides and sources connect
08Where can I find BenBiz & mindbugnush and its sources?

The BenBiz & mindbugnush page brings together the pilot’s purpose, preparations and ways to participate. You can also reach the educators’ photographs and original documents from there.

Explore BenBiz & mindbugnush
Children and adults working with worksheets around a long table during a workshop.
From a previous workshop shared by the educators.

BenBiz & mindbugnush

Explore the programme in the educators’ own words.

To find out what the Nörokripto programme involves, start with the materials prepared by Şeref Gökmen and Elif Özcan. Explore their educational texts, original PDFs, posters and photographs from previous workshops.

The educators’ original texts and documents are kept in Turkish, unchanged.

Adults listening and sharing views around a table; representative illustration.
Adults discussing a shared proposal · Representative illustration

Shared Decisions · Deciding together

How do we turn a proposal into a shared decision?

You might want to change a group’s meeting time or make an unclear part of the website easier to understand. In Shared Decisions, you describe the need and refine your proposal with other people’s views. You can vote on topics where you are eligible, then follow how the decision is put into practice.

  • Proposals and views
  • Votes and reasons
  • Action and follow-up

You can read the guide and try its voting calculation without an account. The exercise creates no real vote or record. To take part in the app, use a verified, active member account.

Learning through images

Picture a topic before you explore it.

Sometimes a scene helps you understand an idea. These two illustrations show people learning together and a path from a question to the sources behind it.

Seven adults learning around a table with picture cards and a map; two people use hand gestures to communicate. Representative illustration.
A representative illustration of shared learning through sign language and picture cards.
A blank card, picture cards, a source folder and an open notebook on a wooden table, linked by a yellow cord. Representative illustration.
Question → topic → guide → original source → shared learning. A representative illustration of this path through picture cards.

Today’s work comes first

What guides the work today?

You may want to know how a circle forms, how compensation is agreed or where to begin with a project. These ten topics point you to the pages that explain today’s approach.

Questions you may have

Start with your question.

Open a question to read a short answer. When you want more detail, follow the links below it to the relevant page or guide.

Can I exchange without a product?

Yes. You can offer work for a product, a product for a service or short-term use of a space. Both sides discuss what they offer and the terms of the exchange. Time freely given without expecting a return belongs to the solidarity route.

How can I take part in decisions?

With a verified, active account, you can propose, share views and vote where you are eligible. The guide explains who can take part in each area. The starting rule requires at least 60% participation by eligible voters and at least 60% yes votes among votes cast. Try the calculation without an account; it creates no real vote.

Why does BenBiz exist?

Putting a good idea into practice may take people, a place, knowledge or tools. BenBiz aims to bring these resources together around a shared need and make compensation clear from the start. We want unseen work to have a voice, with care for nature and people’s limits.

How does a Solidarity Circle form?

It can begin with a shared need, such as finding a venue for a learning group. People discuss what they can offer, who will do what, expenses and compensation from the start. We call the small group working around that agreement a Solidarity Circle.

Is expecting no return the same as waiting for compensation?

No. Freely given support is one choice; leaving agreed compensation outstanding is another. Payment for living costs, outstanding contributions and any time-limited sharing of a surplus have separate terms. Follow an everyday example to see the difference.

What does the Value and Justice Engine assess?

DÇM‑0.3 is a trial model for examining a specific contribution. It first separates pay, expenses, donations and shared contributions, then uses twenty criteria, evidence, two independent reviews and the Justice Gates. A score does not measure a person’s worth or create a decision, economic entitlement or payment by itself.

What did the ten trials teach us?

Ten hypothetical cases showed where we might go wrong when applying the same rules to pay, donations, care work, risk and founding contributions. A high score, for example, does not automatically mean a larger share. These trials do not replace human review of real contribution records.

Can I challenge a decision or assessment?

The method is built around being able to see the reasons for a result affecting you and raise an objection. Criteria and reasons enter the record, and assessments are subject to human approval. The related guide explains the rules and responsibilities along that route.

Which project are we working on now?

Our current preparation focuses on the BenBiz & mindbugnush. Programme and participation terms appear on its page as they become clear. Bursa Şifahane, mentioned in the founding documents, is a historical example of how the thinking developed; read it in that context.

Can I contribute without joining a circle?

Yes. You can explore the Guest area without an account. With an Explorer Member account, follow open developments and share questions, sources or experiences for the website, Reading Area and ObaNova guide. You do not have to join a circle for this. Circle-specific tasks and communication open with that circle’s approval.

Where do the Store, BenAkçe and BenGram stand today?

You can explore BenBiz Store shelves and share needs and contributions in Exchange. A representative shopping rehearsal is also available; real sales and payments are not open yet. BenAkçe and BenGram are described for information and trials; they are not in use as money, gold, investment or payment products.

Which should I follow if an older document and a current page differ?

For today’s workflow, consult the dated web guide and the relevant current page. The original PDF is kept unchanged as a source showing how the thinking developed. You can read them side by side with those different purposes in mind.

Where can we begin working together?

Start by saying what you want to do, what you can offer and where you need support. With people who complement you, choose a small task you can carry, look at its result and share what you learn. The guide brings these five steps and today’s tools together.

Will every ObaNova settlement have the same activities?

Each oba can take shape through the interests and specialisms of its people and the conditions of its place. One might focus on farming, another on education, production or research. Learning from small trials is shared; common principles and mutual help connect the obas. This is long-term work we will develop together.

Joining · application · website

Three guides for your first steps.

You may want to open an account, follow a task in the app or find something on the website. Choose the guide you need and read the steps relevant to you.

Working together

How can we keep working together?

We may all be keen while talking about an idea. Once work begins, our time, needs and what we can offer differ. In BenBiz, we want to discuss those differences early so everyone can choose a contribution they can manage.

When planning a small gathering, one person might offer a space, another prepare the announcement and someone else have just an hour to spare. These five steps help us discuss needs and limits while sharing the work.

  1. Say what you need and can manage

    Are you looking for help or offering something? Share the time you can spare and where you need support.

  2. Meet people who complement you

    Talk with others interested in the same need. Explore what each person can offer; you do not all need the same skills.

  3. Choose a small task together

    Agree what will be done, who will take it on and when it should be finished. Discuss expenses and compensation before starting.

  4. Look at the result together

    Was the task finished, and did it meet the need? See where the effort helped and what support is still missing.

  5. Share what you learned

    Note what worked and where you struggled. Share the learning without disclosing personal information so the next task can benefit from it.

ObaNova guide · 0.3

Shape ObaNova together.

One oba might focus on farming, another on crafts, education or research. What it could do depends on the knowledge of the people forming it and the conditions of the place. Shared principles connect these different places.

A conceptual ObaNova illustration tracing a possible research pathway from hemp fields to fibre, weaving and building components
This conceptual illustration traces a possible pathway from hemp fields to fibre, weaving and building materials. Hemp is one production area we want to explore in ObaNova; the image does not show an operating site.

The guide explores personal space in shared living, production and research through seven topics. Each sets out what we know, what needs checking and where a contribution could help.

You can offer a place, tools, knowledge or experience, or share a need or research question. You do not need a finished project.

  1. Where the “I” and the “We” touch the ground
  2. Together, without becoming the same
  3. Specialisation and living R&D
  4. Today, a first trial, research and the horizon
  5. Hemp: a production pathway under inquiry
  6. From a need to a Solidarity Circle
  7. From contribution to shared learning

You can read the guide without an account. Once you have verified your email, you can leave a note with your Explorer Member account; circle membership is not required.

This contribution path creates no promise of residency, a role, partnership, entitlement or payment.

Five guides to DÇM‑0.3

How can we assess a contribution?

When we see a finished piece of work, preparation, care and follow-up can go unnoticed. The Value and Justice Engine (DÇM‑0.3) is a trial model exploring criteria for discussing these different contributions. Choose the guide you need.

  1. Purpose

    Value and Justice Engine · DÇM‑0.3

    Read how work, risk, value created and continuity are examined. See why pay, expenses and donations are kept separate from contribution scores.

  2. Trial steps

    Laboratory Guide

    Follow the screen journey from preparing a trial record through two independent reviews and the checks for fairness.

  3. Ten examples

    Calibration and Scenario Notebook

    Compare how ten hypothetical cases treat pay, donations, care work and founding contributions. See why a high score is not enough on its own.

  4. Changes

    Work and Change Log

    Read which rules changed after the trials, why they changed and how earlier results are preserved.

  5. Today’s status

    Today’s Application Status

    Learn which laboratory steps you can try, what the results mean and what needs to be completed before real economic use.

Contribute to the Reading Area

One question can improve the explanation.

If a sentence is unclear, you notice an error or your experience differs, you can share it with us. Your questions and notes can help us improve the explanation together.

You can read the guides without an account. To leave a note, an Explorer Member account with a verified email address is enough; you do not need to join a circle or take on a task.

Open Reading Area contributions
  1. Locate your note

    Choose the guide your note relates to and, if useful, a specific section. Select the type that fits: question, wording suggestion, correction, objection, experience or source.

  2. Follow the reply

    Follow your note in “My Reading Contributions” in the app. You can see the publishing team’s reply, any request for clarification, the outcome and the route for reconsideration.

  3. Keep a record of the change

    Two independent people review changes affecting principles. If the text changes, Turkish and English are updated together, and the earlier wording remains on record.

Three different reading paths

How much detail do you need?

If you’re new to BenBiz, start with the short introduction. If you want to explore further or prepare to work with a team, the other two paths take you through the relevant sources in order.

  1. 30–45 minutes

    Quick introduction

    If you’re new to BenBiz

    Read why BenBiz began, what a Solidarity Circle is and what responsibilities come with the invitation to join.

    4 guides · in reading order

    Begin this path
  2. 1.5–2.5 hours

    Whole-system understanding

    If you want to understand the approach in depth

    Read the main sections in order and think through work, compensation and sharing with an example. This path can help you bring your questions to a shared discussion.

    9 guides · in reading order

    Begin this path
  3. 6–7 hours

    Practice and current projects

    If you’re preparing to work together

    Read the principles and working arrangements together as your team prepares. The sequence also includes digital design, DÇM‑0.3 trials, ObaNova and participation guides.

    29 guides · in reading order

    Begin this path

The times are approximate reading and working periods, including time for discussion. You can read the web guides in less time, without an account. The unchanged source PDFs remain in Turkish.

Current guides · original sources

The traces of an evolving idea.

Start with the current guides to learn how things work today. Read the original sources to see how the BenBiz idea developed. Choose a topic below or search with a word that interests you.

Current today
For how things work today.
Developing work
Trials and research.
Original source
First texts and their history.

Choose a topic

31 guides

Participation and shared decisions

1 guide
OKParticipation and shared decisionsCurrent today

Current guide 0.1 · 10 September 2026

Shared Decisions · From a voice to shared work

Discover how a proposal is heard, how 60% participation and 60% approval shape a decision, and how shared work is followed through.

Essence: A living community gives people a real way to influence what they share.

VotingParticipationAbstentionProposalsDAOShared decisions
Illustrated account · Teaching calculationOpen guide

Exchange and contribution

1 guide
T1Exchange and contributionCurrent today

Current web guide 1.4 · 24 October 2026

BenBiz Exchange — A Guide from Needs to Contributions

Shelves in a corner, an unused afternoon, a familiar skill: what could change when they meet someone else’s need? Follow the examples through to your first listing.

Essence: Something you no longer need could be the missing piece that lets someone else begin.

ExchangeNeedsContributionsWorkSpaceVolunteeringMixed contribution
13 min web guideOpen guide

In-depth guides

4 guides
PZRIn-depth guidesOriginal source

Current guide

BenBiz Store · Complete guide

The full guide to maker stories, shared production, exchanges, trust and participation.

Essence: Know the product and its maker together.

PazarStrawderiTakas
DERIn-depth guidesOriginal source

Current guide

Explore BenBiz in depth

Why BenBiz, the bag example, the application, tools and participation in depth.

Essence: Why BenBiz, the bag example, the application, tools and participation in depth.

BenBizIn depth
DERIn-depth guidesOriginal source

Current guide

The complete journal

Earlier writing, notes from the beginning, sample narratives and publishing principles.

Essence: Earlier writing, notes from the beginning, sample narratives and publishing principles.

BenBizIn depth
DERIn-depth guidesOriginal source

Current guide

Guide to meeting people

Profile visibility, meeting through interests and skills, responsibilities and contributions.

Essence: Profile visibility, meeting through interests and skills, responsibilities and contributions.

BenBizIn depth

Current guides

2 guides
BGCurrent guidesCurrent today

Informational model and converter

BenAkçe · BenGram

Contribution records, agreements, a gold-based reference model and dated converter.

Essence: Records, rights and actual payment remain distinct; wallets and payment services are unavailable.

BenAkçeBenGramValue reference
Y1Current guidesOriginal source

Current design guide · 6 September 2026

BenBiz · Like a Living Organism

How can we build a shared place where everyone brings their own colour, joins as their intention and strength allow, and sees where their contribution goes?

Essence: Being alive together does not mean everyone is always busy. It means a need can be heard, the right people can meet freely, their work can reach someone and what they learn is not forgotten.

Living communityIntentionCompleting one another
6 min web guide
30 page original PDF · Turkish
Open guide

Getting started

1 guide
00Getting startedOriginal source

Working guide

Reading and Working Guide

Where should we begin, in what order should we read, and how can we test what we understand together?

Essence: The aim is not to approve a ready-made idea, but to understand the same thing well enough to question it together.

ReadingShared language
2 min web guide
9 page original PDF · Turkish
Open guide

Core narrative

7 guides
01Core narrativeOriginal source

Part 1 of 7

Why Do We Need a New Foundation?

Why do good intentions also need fair relationships to support them from the very beginning?

Essence: The continuation of good work should not depend on the same few people continually giving themselves up.

JusticeShared foundation
2 min web guide
32 page original PDF · Turkish
Open guide
02Core narrativeOriginal source

Part 2 of 7

What Is a Solidarity Circle?

A working foundation that brings different resources around a shared purpose and clear responsibilities.

Essence: Equal human dignity; fairness when contributions are assessed.

Completing resourcesFairness
4 min web guide
42 page original PDF · Turkish
Open guide
03Core narrativeCurrent today

Current account · 24 October 2026

What is my share in the value we create together?

Giving freely and waiting for compensation are different choices. Explore living costs, outstanding contributions and sharing value for an agreed period.

Essence: Choosing not to receive compensation today does not mean giving up an agreed right.

ContributionRightsBen AkçeLiving costsFounding workSharing
9 min web guide
37 page reference PDF · updated guide
Open guide
04Core narrativeOriginal source

Part 4 of 7

How Does the System Actually Work?

Connecting purpose, need, contribution, records, decisions and sharing in a traceable cycle.

Essence: A promise, a completed contribution and a resulting right must remain separately visible.

WorkflowContribution assessmentAgreement
3 min web guide
43 page original PDF · Turkish
Open guide
05Core narrativeOriginal source

Part 5 of 7

What Kind of Future Are We Offering Young People?

Offering more than belonging: room to develop ideas, earn a living, take part in decisions and experiment safely.

Essence: Young people should be able to become co-founders in the present, not merely inheritors of the future.

Young peopleFoundingFuture
2 min web guide
43 page original PDF · Turkish
Open guide
06Core narrativeOriginal source

Part 6 of 7 · Not today’s pilot

Historical Practice Example: Bursa Şifahane

An example exploring how a place, specialist knowledge and social trust could connect through one shared way of working.

Essence: A ready building and a strong network of people do not automatically create a fair system.

BursaHistorical exampleContinuity
2 min web guide
41 page original PDF · Turkish
Open guide
07Core narrativeOriginal source

Part 7 of 7

Invitation and Shared Responsibility

Moving from liking an idea to carrying a defined and sustainable contribution together.

Essence: An honest “I cannot do this for now” is more trustworthy than an unsustainable “I will always be here.”

ParticipationResponsibilityObjection
2 min web guide
42 page original PDF · Turkish
Open guide

Practice

1 guide
08PracticeOriginal source

Hypothetical example

Applied Simulation

Using one example month to distinguish direct rights, operating needs, the common pool and shared funds.

Essence: Contribution points illustrate the distribution of a clearly separated common contribution pool, not total revenue.

Contribution assessmentDouble countingCalculation
2 min web guide
35 page original PDF · Turkish
Open guide

Digital design

2 guides
09Digital designOriginal source

Design document 0.1 · August 2026

Digital Ecosystem: Core Architecture

Identity, need, work, rights and decision layers connecting autonomous circles through a shared protocol.

Essence: One digital doorway does not mean every circle is managed from one centre.

DigitalPrivacyArchitecture
2 min web guide
30 page original PDF · Turkish
Open guide
10Digital designOriginal source

Design document 0.1 · August 2026

User Journey 01

A human journey from discovery and mutual fit to a first task and visible contribution and rights.

Essence: Creating an account is not the same as entering a circle or receiving unlimited authority.

ParticipationAgreementDigital
2 min web guide
19 page original PDF · Turkish
Open guide

Working annexes

3 guides
AWorking annexesOriginal source

Summary presentation for the core team

The Story of a Shared Foundation

Explaining together why we began, what we are building and how first responsibilities can be shared.

Essence: The Solidarity Circle is neither unlimited sacrifice nor a compromise with a system concerned only with profit.

Shared languageIntroduction
2 min web guide
18 page original PDF · Turkish
Open guide
BWorking annexesOriginal source

Preliminary introduction · August 2026

Digital App · Core Team

An early account of how principles about people, work and trust could become functions in a mobile experience.

Essence: Technology exists to make contributions and reasons visible, not to pass judgment.

PilotDigitalIstanbul
2 min web guide
15 page original PDF · Turkish
Open guide
CWorking annexesOriginal source

Pilot 0.1 · August 2026

Digital App · Technical Annex

A technical frame connecting the mobile surface, operating rules and the memory of records.

Essence: The user sees a simple path; behind it, every record remains connected to the next step.

TechnicalTrustPilot
2 min web guide
15 page original PDF · Turkish
Open guide

DÇM‑0.3 laboratory

4 guides
L1DÇM‑0.3 laboratoryDeveloping work

Current experimental model · 5 September 2026

Value and Justice Engine · DÇM‑0.3

The current engine framework for making unlike contributions visible while protecting direct rights, human dignity and reasoned shared decisions.

Essence: The engine does not measure a person’s worth. It shows the information, explanations and evidence used to discuss one specific contribution.

DÇM‑0.3JusticeContribution
4 min web guide
9 page reference PDF · updated guide
Open guide
L2DÇM‑0.3 laboratoryDeveloping work

Practice guide · DÇM‑0.3 / CAL‑001

How to Use the DÇM‑0.3 Laboratory

A guide to the laboratory journey from a contribution event through blind reviews and Justice Gates to an explained result.

Essence: The screen answers “why is this record in this state?” before the number can carry meaning through its scope, evidence and open blockers.

LaboratoryJustice GatesObjection
3 min web guide
9 page reference PDF · updated guide
Open guide
L3DÇM‑0.3 laboratoryDeveloping work

Calibration 0.1 · Ten hypothetical cases

Calibration and Scenario Notebook

The first comparison testing whether the engine sends the right value to the right channel across ten different tensions.

Essence: Calibration is not about making scores look attractive. It keeps every result—including a high number—inside boundaries of rights, scope, evidence and justice.

ScenariosCalibrationCAL‑001
3 min web guide
23 page reference PDF · updated guide
Open guide
L5DÇM‑0.3 laboratoryDeveloping work

Available laboratory · released 5 September 2026

What DÇM‑0.3 Does—and Does Not Do—Today

A status record separating the experience the DÇM‑0.3 interface actually offers today from the economic and governance layers not yet opened.

Essence: A live laboratory does not mean that a real entitlement and payment system is complete.

Current statusApplicationBoundaries
3 min web guide
9 page reference PDF · updated guide
Open guide

Updated laboratory

1 guide
L4Updated laboratoryDeveloping work

Updated record · since 5 September 2026

Working Notebook and Change History

A record of settled principles, experimental decisions, scenario outcomes and application rules that keeps earlier decisions visible.

Essence: Staying current does not mean rewriting the past. It means showing what changed, why, by whom and when.

ChangesReasonsRecords
3 min web guide
9 page reference PDF · updated guide
Open guide

Updated projects

1 guide
O1Updated projectsDeveloping work

Shared design 0.3 · 11 September 2026

ObaNova · Current Project Guide

A current guide to how the “I” and the “We” might take root in shared life through specialisation, living R&D and small, honest trials.

Essence: ObaNova is not a ready-made plan for life. It is a vision for a network of settlements where people can remain themselves while living, making, learning and inquiring together.

ObaNovaR&DSpecialisationHempShared design
6 min web guide
7 page reference PDF · updated guide
Open guide

Getting-started guides

3 guides
R1Getting-started guidesCurrent today

Current guide 1.5 · 16 September 2026

Joining BenBiz

A clear path from account-free discovery to Explorer Membership, website and Reading Area contributions, and circle membership.

Essence: You do not need to be accepted into a circle before approaching BenBiz; an Explorer Member account gives you a door of your own.

ExplorerMembershipParticipation path
6 min web guide
19 page reference PDF · updated guide
Open guide
R2Getting-started guidesCurrent today

Current guide 1.10 · 24 October 2026

BenBiz Application Route Guide

Find your route from membership and tasks to Istanbul education requests, personal QR links, source confirmation, group preparation and account tracking.

Essence: Choose what you want to do first; let the application open only the door that task needs.

ApplicationExplorerCircle workspace
20 min web guide
15 page reference PDF · updated guide
Open guide
R3Getting-started guidesCurrent today

Current guide 1.9 · 16 September 2026

How to Use the BenBiz Website

Find the current route from the homepage to the Istanbul education pilot, original educational sources and application tracking in the app.

Essence: Do not try to read everything; choose what you need first, then open the right door.

WebsiteReading AreaContribution
10 min web guide
9 page reference PDF · updated guide
Open guide

The words we use

Let the same word carry the same meaning.

You do not need to memorise these terms. Choose a word you get stuck on, open its short explanation and follow the related guide if you want to read more.

From the text to the table

Test what we read together.

The same text can raise a different question for each of us. These four steps help us share what we understood, discuss doubts and decide on the next step we can take together.

  1. State the essence

    Explain the main idea in your own words. Listen to one another to see whether you are starting from the same understanding.

  2. Make the connection

    Is there a question left open from an earlier reading? Discuss what this guide adds and how it connects with the other topics.

  3. Name the doubt

    Ask about what you do not understand, and name risks and objections separately. Discuss which point needs an explanation, further research or a shared decision.

  4. Bring it into practice

    What would this idea change in everyday life? Decide how it could become a behaviour, rule, task or screen, and who will take the first step.

At the end, make a short note of what you understood together, the questions still open and who will carry each next step. You can return to it at your next meeting.

Open the working guide

From reading to shared work

Where you get stuck can make this clearer for everyone.

If a question, correction or example from your own life comes to mind while reading, you can share it.

In the app’s “My Reading Contributions” screen, you can follow the reply to your note and see whether the text changes.

Visit measurement & privacy